I have black/dark brown hair so I was looking for a good soft eyebrow pencil color that has no red tint to it. Finally found my HG brow pencil in #2! The #2 shade has a soft brown color with no red tint at all. I've used 4 of the #2 shade and tried the gray one as well just to try out and see the difference between the two. The gray one is great if you want a darker fuller looking brow as it's as the color states grey looking. I personally prefer #2 in most days but use the gray when I want strong brows to compliment my strong eye makeup.
Definitely love these babies~~ :D