Both really pretty!As expected etude has great tints.For vampire red the colour is really deep and dark even darker than the photo.It's really pretty and great for winter.When you make a gradient lip look it looks amazing!Couldnt be more satisfied!Recommended for all skin colours especially yellow undetone skin.Also I've used other brand tints and they dried my lips to the point I had dead cells at the end of the day but this one is not as drying!Great product I'll make sure to get other colours too!

For kumquat red,at first I thought the colour didn't fit my face since it looked more to the pink side rather than the orange when applied fully on the lips but when I tried in just on the center of my lips it looks really pretty!This colour is recommended for people with pink undertone skin.