I got this as a free sample (along with Dorothyco waterproof mascara--the best mascara you will EVER buy). It turned out to be a little too red for me, but it still worked since I have a red tint to my hair. The only thing I didn't like was that it didn't come with an eyebrow comb, as most eyebrow pencils do. It's fine, because I can use other eyebrow pencil's combs... or you could easily by a super cheap one at any beauty/makeup store or your local drugstore... but still. It is a little inconvenient for you to have to carry two items (wow, first world problems, I know).